June 23, 2024


Advocacy. Mediation. Success.

After 20 years in prison, man found innocent of a murder

Los Angeles County Dist. Atty. George Gascón (Irfan Khan/Los Angeles Periods)

Alexander Torres was convicted of murder on shaky evidence.

A witness to the capturing on New Year’s Eve in 2000 told police at to start with that the assailant hadn’t seemed to know his target, when Torres had a lengthy background with the gentleman. The witness changed his tale a lot more than once and named Torres as the shooter only just after numerous rounds of interviews.

An additional witness initially recognized Torres as the killer, but admitted afterwards that he had picked him from a picture lineup only simply because he bore the closest resemblance to the shooter.

And Torres experienced a good alibi: He had been celebrating the new yr at his mother’s dwelling in one more component of Paramount when Martin “Casper” Guitron was gunned down. A solid on his hand produced it unlikely he would have been ready even to pull the induce.

Torres was sentenced to 40 a long time to life in jail. But after investing a lot more than 20 many years behind bars, the now-42-calendar year-old has been cleared of the killing and launched from jail.

In April, after a evaluate of the scenario, a decide observed Torres factually innocent, concluding that a collection of missteps had led to his arrest and wrongful conviction.

The judge’s get followed a evaluation of the scenario by the California Innocence Job and the place of work of Los Angeles County Dist. Atty. George Gascón, who campaigned on a guarantee to choose a more durable seem at questionable convictions. Torres’ sentence was vacated in October with little fanfare, but his release was declared at a news meeting Wednesday arranged by Gascón’s business office.

In a statement, the district legal professional apologized to Torres and praised the function of his revamped Conviction Integrity Unit. “While it is this office’s job to maintain people accountable for the harm they trigger, it is similarly essential that we critically reexamine past convictions,” the assertion browse.

The exoneration could provide a raise for the embattled district legal professional, who is below large criticism from within and outside the house his office environment about his procedures aimed at reducing mass incarceration.

Although his predecessor, Jackie Lacey, frequently touted the do the job of her office’s scenario critique unit, she limited the varieties of cases the device could evaluation, leaving it fairly hamstrung compared with identical models in other significant metropolitan areas these kinds of as Chicago, Houston and New York.

When he took place of work, Gascón appointed to his transition team a selection of civil legal rights attorneys and lawyers with expertise in reviewing the integrity of past convictions. He also pledged to alter the way the business office reviewed these circumstances.

Mike Semanchik, a running legal professional with the California Innocence Project, explained that while more could nevertheless be finished, the device beneath Gascón has “definitely invested a ton far more time, effort and hard work and assets into investigating these kinds of instances than prior administrations have.”

The California Innocence Task is examining about a dozen other convictions with the district attorney’s business, Semanchik stated.

Audrey McGinn, an attorney who worked on Torres’ exoneration for the California Innocence Undertaking, stated that it is unclear what or who was to blame for the wrongful conviction, but that usually investigators fork out much more awareness to evidence that supports what they now consider.

“I think it is a products of tunnel eyesight and disregarding the red flags, in particular when you place a picture in front of a witness and say, ‘This is the person,’” she mentioned. “He was an straightforward focus on, and it was effortless to establish motive.”

Guitron was going for walks with a friend near Somerset Boulevard and El Camino Avenue in Paramount, a city of about 55,000 residents east of Compton, when a blue 1990s Chevrolet Caprice stopped in the middle of the road. A guy got out and walked up to Guitron, repeatedly asking, “Are you Casper? Are you Casper?” applying Guitron’s road identify, before capturing him.

In a joint motion for factual innocence, lawyers for equally sides agreed that Torres would have recognized Guitron, with whom he’d had a prolonged-simmering feud stemming from their membership in rival gangs. The motion also cited the accounts of many household customers who documented that at the time of the capturing Torres was celebrating New Year’s and his mother’s birthday at her dwelling in another aspect of town. Moreover, no murder weapon was recovered and no other bodily proof connected Torres to the scene, according to the submitting.

The work to exonerate Torres bought a substantial break when his family hired a private investigator, who managed to monitor down the driver of the Caprice. The driver eventually led authorities to the person they now imagine was the shooter. That male, like the driver, has due to the fact been arrested in the Paramount slaying and has been incarcerated considering the fact that the early 2000s just after his conviction for a collection of armed robberies.

In accordance to the Nationwide Registry of Exonerations, 161 men and women have been exonerated of murders and other major crimes in the state very last calendar year — adding to the hundreds of individuals freed given that the late 1980s. In all, they put in a mixed 1,849 several years behind bars. Virtually fifty percent experienced been charged with a murder they failed to commit. Black individuals accounted for a disproportionate range of the wrongfully convicted.

In a the vast majority of the cases from very last 12 months, the wrongful convictions resulted from “official misconduct,” possibly by prosecutors, police or forensic professionals, the firm uncovered, though 47 were owing to mistaken identifications by witnesses. An more 19 exonerations arrived about because of “tested bogus confessions,” the corporation decided.

UC Davis regulation professor Irene Oritseweyinmi Joe explained that scenarios like Torres’ should really induce an intensive, major-down critique of what went incorrect. Law enforcement, prosecutors, judges and even community defenders should really all deal with the similar scrutiny, specified the important roles they enjoy when the justice program won’t function.

“Each and every motion that could’ve been taken even if it wasn’t expected to be taken at the time [should be] reviewed to make confident that it doesn’t come about again,” Joe claimed.

For the document:
9:19 p.m. June 1, 2022: An earlier model of this write-up said
a choose located Alexander Torres factually harmless very last thirty day period. It was in April.

This tale initially appeared in Los Angeles Times.