Justices appoint Utah law professor to defend structure of Federal Housing Finance Agency

Claud Mccoid

The Supreme Court on Monday appointed Aaron Nielson, a professor at Brigham Young University’s J. Reuben Clark Law School, as a “friend of the court” in Collins v. Mnuchin, in which the justices are most likely to hear argument this fall. Nielson, an skilled on administrative law, will protect the constitutionality of the structure of the Federal Housing Finance Agency after the federal authorities declined to do so.

The situation is a dispute concerning shareholders of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and the FHFA, which turned the conservator for Fannie and Freddie after the 2008 economic disaster, above the FHFA’s 2012 funding settlement with the Treasury Division. 1 of the thoughts that the justices agreed in July to make a decision is no matter whether the FHFA’s structure violates the Constitution simply because the company is headed by a one director, who can be taken out by the president only “for lead to.” In proceedings in advance of the comprehensive U.S. Court of Appeals for the fifth Circuit and in its transient opposing evaluate in the Supreme Court, the Justice Division did not protect the removing restriction. The FHFA defended the restriction in the court docket of appeals but has not appeared in the Supreme Court.

Going through the prospect that neither aspect in the situation would protect the removing restriction, the justices appointed Nielson, a previous law clerk to Justice Samuel Alito who was a spouse in the Washington, D.C., business of Kirkland & Ellis in advance of likely into academia Nielson carries on to serve “of counsel” at the firm. This sort of appointments are not unusual at the Supreme Court, and the justices have a longstanding tradition of making it possible for the circuit justice for the circuit from which the situation hails to appoint the attorney who will transient and argue the situation as a “friend of the court docket.” The circuit justice – in this article, Alito, who handles unexpected emergency appeals from the fifth Circuit – will frequently contact on a previous clerk, usually supplying the attorney, as is accurate for Nielson, his 1st opportunity to surface in advance of the justices. On the other hand, Justice Elena Kagan departed final expression from this tradition when she appointed Paul Clement, a previous U.S. solicitor typical who has argued above 100 instances, to protect the constitutionality of the leadership structure of the Client Economic Protection Bureau.

This article was originally released at Howe on the Court.

The article Justices appoint Utah law professor to protect structure of Federal Housing Finance Agency appeared 1st on SCOTUSblog.

Next Post

SCOTUS spotlight: Tom Goldstein on ‘hitting singles’ as an oral advocate

Tom Goldstein, the publisher of SCOTUSblog and partner at Goldstein & Russell, P.C., has argued more than 40 cases before the Supreme Court since his first oral argument in 1999. On this week’s episode of SCOTUStalk, Amy Howe interviews Goldstein on what it’s like to advocate before the nine and […]