October 1, 2023


Advocacy. Mediation. Success.

What happens next in the Musk-Twitter saga?

Tesla CEO Elon Musk and Twitter are bracing for a lawful combat soon after the billionaire explained Friday he was abandoning his $44 billion bid for the social media organization.

Twitter is vowing to problem Musk in courtroom to uphold the agreement. Shares of Twitter slid much more than 11% on Monday. This is a seem at what could transpire subsequent.


There are a ton of motives why Musk could have experienced 2nd ideas. But he alleged Friday that Twitter has unsuccessful to deliver ample information and facts about the number of pretend accounts it has.

Twitter said very last month that it was producing out there to Musk a “firehose” of public raw details on hundreds of thousands and thousands of day-to-day tweets. But Musk’s legal professionals have argued that the business was giving Musk with at times “incomplete or unusable information” and a lot less info than it presents some of its major buyers.

Twitter stated last 7 days it employs a combine of community and non-public data to identify the quantity of spam. Personal person information isn’t available publicly and as a result just isn’t in the information “firehose” that it gave Musk. That would involve IP addresses, mobile phone numbers and spot. Twitter said these kinds of personal information assists avoid misidentifying serious accounts as spam.

Twitter has explained for yrs in regulatory filings that it believes about 5% of the accounts on the platform are fake. But on Monday Musk continued to taunt the corporation, using Twitter, around what he has explained as a lack of facts.


Twitter declared its intent to sue Musk. The firm could have pushed for a $1 billion separation price that Musk agreed to shell out below these situation. As a substitute, it seems ready to combat to finish the buy, which the company’s board has approved and CEO Parag Agrawal has insisted he needs to consummate.

The chair of Twitter’s board, Bret Taylor, tweeted Friday that the board is “committed to closing the transaction on the selling price and conditions agreed upon” with Musk and “plans to go after legal action to implement the merger settlement. We are confident we will prevail in the Delaware Court docket of Chancery.”

The demo court in Delaware regularly handles business enterprise disputes among the the numerous firms, including Twitter, that are integrated there.

WHO’S Going TO Get?

It is really just about unattainable to predict the consequence of any protracted legal battle. But law and business professionals consider Twitter possible has the more powerful scenario.

Morningstar analyst Ali Mogharabi pointed out that Twitter has explained its estimate of pretend and spam accounts for yrs in regulatory filings when explicitly noting that the number could possibly not be precise specified the use of information samples and interpretation.

Given latest industry circumstances, Mogharabi claimed, Twitter may well also have a strong argument that the layoffs and firings of the previous months represent “an normal course of business.”

“Many technological know-how corporations have begun to control fees by decreasing headcount and/or delaying including personnel,” he stated. “The resignations of Twitter staff members are unable to with certainty be attributed to any modify in how Twitter has operated considering that Musk’s supply was recognized by the board and shareholders.”

The circumstance could also end in a settlement, for occasion with the two sides negotiating a reduce price. If Musk wins, you can find also the concern of the $1 billion breakup payment. He can definitely pay for it, but will he want to fork out?


The Musk saga has been, to set it mildly, a distraction for Twitter’s workers, executives and even consumers. Some workforce have stop, while some others were laid off or fired. Career offers have been rescinded and discretionary spending curtailed.

“For Twitter this fiasco is a nightmare situation,” Wedbush analyst Dan Ives, who follows the organization, wrote Monday. He reported the end result would be “an Everest-like uphill climb for Parag & Co.” supplied issues above employee morale and retention, advertiser problems and other troubles.”

Twitter by itself is unlikely to go any where irrespective of whether or not or not it improvements hands. But if the turmoil proceeds it could scare away advertisers. If too several engineers and other workforce go away, the platform’s quality could experience as perfectly.

“The one particular dazzling spot is that if (Twitter) is in the long run victorious in the courts, it could probably just take north of the $1B in split-up expenses that Musk could have to pay,” mentioned CFRA Analyst Angelo Zino.


Even if Musk loses the courtroom situation, some observers question if the world’s richest guy will abide by the result. Which is in component dependent on his antagonistic method to unfavorable steps from the U.S. Securities and Trade Commission in excess of Musk’s tweets declaring he had the funding to choose Tesla personal in 2018.

That led to a securities fraud settlement with the SEC requiring that his tweets be authorised by a Tesla legal professional just before becoming printed. But the SEC later investigated irrespective of whether the Tesla CEO violated the settlement with tweets final November asking Twitter followers if he must market 10% of his Tesla inventory.

Musk experienced argued that the agency can not take action about his tweets without having court authorization. This time, even so, he could very effectively facial area an true court purchase to fork out the $1 billion separation payment — or to finish the acquisition even if he isn’t going to want to.


AP Technological innovation Author Matt O’Brien contributed to this tale.